Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The thing is MS and Apple won't negotiate on any of this. They have never been involved with open standards and respectively pushed WMV and MOV formats instead.

You have to move forward under the presumption that neither will ever cooperate in a macroscopic sense, especially after Google caved and gave up making youtube webm based.

You still have to make the best solutions, and speak why they are the best, and hope everyone else will switch so that inevitably the dinosaurs do too. Because you can't reason with a trex.



> especially after Google caved and gave up making youtube webm based

They didn't remove h264 from Chrome, but when I watch videos on youtube, right click -> stats for nerds it lists the video as 'video/webm; codecs="vp9"'. That includes videos with ads, which didn't use to be the case.


Any idea when this happened? I only noticed a few days ago and there doesn't seem to be any official announcements or even blog posts about the switch.

I think they used to prompt you to install Flash if you didn't have it too, which it didn't seem to do earlier this week, just played adverts and content via HTML5/H.254 (in IE11) and HTML5/VP8 in Firefox.

After this the next step is probably to start delivering HTML5 in preference to FLash, where possible. Wonder what the plan is for that transition?


No, I hadn't noticed it until testing it for that comment (actually I didn't notice an ad started playing for the first video I clicked on and even the ad itself was webm), though I do feel like I've gotten almost all html5 videos for a while now (I have click to play on for plugins, so the ones that are ready to go stand out).

> After this the next step is probably to start delivering HTML5 in preference to FLash, where possible. Wonder what the plan is for that transition?

Notably, if you go to the html5 youtube page (http://www.youtube.com/html5) in incognito mode in Chrome, it actually says "The HTML5 player is currently used when possible", so I assume this is the default now. That isn't the case in Firefox, where the option to request the html5 player to be the default is still there. Maybe it's a vp9 thing? I don't believe Firefox has included vp9 yet (and the player says: 'codecs="vp8.0, vorbis"')


Ah that's interesting. I actually opted out of HTML5 to see what would happen, but only in Firefox.

Firefox does have VP9, but it doesn't yet have the MSE (Media Source Extension) support that YouTube requires to deliver VP9, though a semi-functional version is available behind a preference in the nightly builds.


> They have never been involved with open standards and respectively pushed WMV and MOV formats instead.

The MPEG-4 file format is .mov, and MPEG-4 onwards are open standards.


I'm pretty sure he meant patent free open standards or freely licensed patents open standards.


And MPEG-4 Systems (the file format) is a patent-free open standard!


Is it? I thought it was just not actively monetized via licence and left as a gray area, like so many other things related to royalty-bearing codecs.

A quick Google gives me this:

http://www.mpegla.com/main/programs/M4S/Pages/Intro.aspx




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: